Key risk indicators (KRIs) are early warning signs that help track potential risk exposures a utility may face. KRIs help monitor how a risk may be changing as well as the risk mitigation effectiveness. In short, KRIs allow a utility to tie potential risk exposures to actual results, making them a valuable tool that links risk analysis to business and operational planning.
To organize the KRIs, use a risk register. The risk register taxonomy has risk categories to drive the risk identification process. Examples of electric utility risk categories include operations, regulatory and political, environmental, customer, market, and technology and cyber.
Next, consider the risk impact associated with each risk. When conducting the initial risk assessment, discuss how the utility would be impacted if a specific risk occurred. The electric utility sector generally focuses on financial, including customer rates and ability to maintain stable financial position; reputation; and safety and security impacts. Table 1 demonstrates a simplified risk register structure template.
To understand the degree of the impact, discuss a scale and time horizon in advance so everyone is working with the same impact rating criteria. The result is a list of individual risks under each Risk Category, for which a KRI is developed.
The organization’s existing key performance indicators (KPIs) and strategic plan metrics are good starting points for KRIs. Using KPIs for KRIs integrates strategic planning with risk management work. If a KPI that also serves as a KRI moves the wrong direction, people across the organization will see it, focusing attention on the risk exposure and the current risk mitigation plan. And if a KPI/KRI moves beneficially, it may indicate the risk is less severe and will be ranked lower in the next risk assessment.
But utilities will not have metrics for every risk, so new metrics must be developed. KRIs should be objective, measurable, and relevant to the risk to be useful. It is very important the key risk indicator is truly an indicator. For example, the low-fuel light on a car dashboard notifying the driver the gas tank needs refilling is far more effective than a reminder in the owner’s manual to monitor the fuel level. The same holds true with KRIs. For example, “number of near-miss incidents” is a better safety risk indicator than “roll-out of new safety manual.”
Table 2 is a simplified KRI table. Under each risk category, two illustrative KRIs appear. The first risk in each category (blue font) uses a standard electric utility KPI and the second risk has a specially drafted KRI (green font) for the risk.
Once metrics are identified, best practice is to develop targets for low, medium, and high risk. This sets a clear direction internally about the objectives to reduce the risks.
Most utility risk management programs identify risk owners for each risk in the risk register. A risk owner is responsible for monitoring the risk, developing a risk mitigation strategy, and reporting periodically on the risk. Therefore, risk owners should identify and monitor KRIs, given they are the most knowledgeable about root causes and consequences of risk exposures. Further, risk owners should also recommend the KRI targets.
KRIs should be reported centrally to a risk manager, so that risk information across the organizations is aggregated and reported to management. A dashboard report is a successful tool to help leaders visualize the KRIs, targets, and actual results. This report efficiently delivers valuable information to decision-makers and policymakers. Once an organization has several reporting cycles, a trend analysis will show change over time.
It is important to note KRIs are helpful for measuring change, but they may not pinpoint the precise reason behind the changing metric. If the business customer satisfaction rating declined, more investigation would be needed, since many factors influence customer satisfaction. For example, complaints about incorrect billing may highlight a customer billing system issue, whereas complaints about frequent outages may point to structural weaknesses in the distribution system. This would likely be supported by a similar negative move in system operating KRIs.
Another reason risk indicators are valuable is they prompt organizations to ask, “Do we have appropriate internal controls to mitigate risk?” Internal controls help an organization maintain compliance with rules and regulations. However, they also help protect the organization from certain risk events. An example is the cost of a utility’s power supply. Utilities without strong energy risk management practices to translate wholesale market prices into potential customer rate impacts are missing a key control for managing future power and fuel costs. Risk limits related to power supply cost management are an example of an internal control to mitigate this potential risk.
In closing, KRIs provide early warning signals. Utility leaders and policymakers must pay close attention to them, just as they do to KPIs. However, it’s important to identify the right KRIs, not just the easy-to-report ones, to ensure the most important information is available for decision-making. If a metric does not yet exist to use for a given risk, put a placeholder in the risk indicators report so this risk is not overlooked. Diligence implementing this last stage of a risk management program is well worth the effort and extra time, for it brings ongoing value to the organization.



